What does underinsurance mean for a high net worth home?
Underinsurance means the amount you have told your insurer is less than the cost of putting things back. With a large home, the gap can be significant in cash terms, even if it looks small as a percentage.
Underinsurance does not only matter on a total loss. Many policies scale down partial claims too, so a modest leak or theft can produce a smaller payment than expected.
How does average work on home insurance?
Average is the reduction of a claim in proportion to the level of underinsurance. If your sum insured is 75% of what it should be, the insurer may pay only 75% of each claim.
Wordings differ in how they express this. One standard home wording has an "inadequate sums insured" condition for both buildings and contents. If the full cost of repair or replacement is more than the sum insured, the claim is reduced in the same proportion.
High-value wordings also tie claims to adequate sums insured. One high-value wording requires contents, art and valuables sums insured to represent the cost of replacing them as new.
Illustrative example: A house should be insured for £3,000,000 but is insured for £2,000,000. A fire causes £300,000 of damage.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Correct sum insured | £3,000,000 |
| Actual sum insured | £2,000,000 |
| Proportion insured | 2/3 |
| Cost of damage | £300,000 |
| Payment if average applies | £200,000 |
| Shortfall borne by the owner | £100,000 |
The figures are round and for illustration only. For more on how average works with older property, see our listed building insurance page.
Why is rebuild cost different from market value?
Rebuild cost and market value measure different things. Market value is what a buyer would pay, including the land and location. Rebuild cost is the cost to demolish, clear and reconstruct the building, including fees.
In prime areas, market value can be far higher than rebuild cost. In the country, or for older and larger homes, rebuild cost can exceed market value, especially where craft materials are involved.
A professional reinstatement cost assessment is the most reliable basis for a large or unusual home. BCIS offers a free online rebuild calculator, but generic tools are built around typical construction. For heritage homes, see our heritage property insurance page.
Where do sums insured usually go wrong?
Sums insured usually go wrong in a handful of predictable places. Most come from changes to the home or its contents that are never passed on to the insurer.
Rebuild cost
- Using market value or purchase price as the buildings sum insured.
- Relying on a figure that has been index-linked for years without a fresh assessment.
- Leaving out outbuildings, pools, garden walls, gates, driveways and tennis courts.
- Omitting professional fees, debris removal or the cost of complying with planning requirements.
- Using standard build rates for traditional or high-specification construction.
Contents
- Estimating contents room by room without an inventory.
- Forgetting items in lofts, cellars, garages, wine stores and outbuildings.
- Underestimating soft furnishings, curtains, rugs, clothing and fitted items.
- Not accounting for replacement cost at today's prices.
Valuables
- Holding jewellery, watches, art or collections above the single-article limit without listing them.
- Relying on old valuations. Valuers warn that jewellery valued more than two years ago is likely to be underinsured.
- Valuing sets item by item instead of as a group. See pairs and sets cover.
Our guide to valuing art, jewellery and collections for insurance explains what a good valuation includes.
How do renovations and acquisitions cause underinsurance?
Renovations and acquisitions raise the value at risk, often without the insurer being told. A new kitchen, basement, extension or garden room can add substantially to the rebuild cost.
Acquisitions work the same way. A painting bought at auction or a watch received as a gift may be uninsured, or capped, until it is added to the schedule.
Some policies give temporary help. One high-value wording covers new contents and art bought during the year, provided you tell the insurer within 60 days of purchase. Miss that window and the item may not be insured, so update the schedule promptly.
Works in progress raise other questions too. Tell your insurer before work starts. Agree how the existing structure and new works will be covered alongside the contractor's own insurances.
Does index-linking prevent underinsurance?
Index-linking helps, but only if the starting figure was right. It adjusts a sum insured in line with a published index, usually monthly or at renewal.
One standard home wording, for example, adjusts buildings sums insured monthly in line with a published house rebuilding cost index. Contents and valuables follow the consumer durables section of the Retail Prices Index. Both apply only where you chose your own sum insured.
An index cannot capture a new extension, a new collection or a figure that was wrong at the outset. A periodic professional review is still needed.
What should be on an annual underinsurance checklist?
A short review before each renewal catches most problems. This table is a practical starting point.
| Area | What to check | Evidence to keep |
|---|---|---|
| Buildings | Date of last reinstatement assessment; any works since | Surveyor's report, invoices for works |
| Outbuildings and grounds | Garages, staff cottages, pools, walls, gates, tennis courts included | Plans, photos |
| Contents | Inventory updated; new furniture, rugs, fixtures added | Room-by-room inventory |
| Valuables | Items above single-article limits specified; valuations current | Valuation certificates, photographs |
| Pairs and sets | Sets valued as a whole | Valuation showing set value |
| Acquisitions | Anything bought or inherited this year added | Receipts, auction invoices |
| Disposals | Items sold or given away removed | Sale records |
| Away from home | Second homes, storage, items kept at a bank | Location list |
| Occupancy | Any planned empty periods or lettings disclosed | Notes for insurer |
Owners of larger estates with cottages and outbuildings can also speak to our high net worth home insurance team.
What else affects how a claim is settled?
The basis of settlement matters as much as the number. Check whether items are covered for replacement or market value, whether there are per-item limits, and what conditions apply to security or valuations.
Also check alternative accommodation limits. A large home can take a long time to rebuild, and those limits can run out.
What to have ready for a review
- Your current schedule and policy wording.
- The figure, date and author of your last rebuild assessment.
- The listing grade or category, if the home is listed.
- Construction of the walls, roof, floors and framing, and the age of each part.
- Details of any works completed since then, with invoices, and any planned works.
- Whether an electrical inspection has been carried out, and when.
- Heating, fire and security protections.
- A contents inventory and current valuations for jewellery, watches and art.
- A list of items bought, inherited or sold this year.
- Details of second homes, storage and any planned empty periods.
- Your claims history for the last five years.





