What value should art and jewellery be insured for?
Art and jewellery are usually insured for the cost of replacing the item with one of the same kind and quality, bought from a reputable retail source. That is generally higher than an auction or resale figure.
For insurance, a valuer usually provides a retail replacement value. It is not based on the price you paid, or on what someone thinks the item would sell for now. It reflects market conditions, provenance, condition and materials.
Getting this right matters because it sets the sum insured. Too low and you risk underinsurance; too high and you pay premium for value you could never recover.
Agreed value vs market value: what is the difference?
Agreed value and market value describe how a claim will be settled. Agreed value means the insurer accepts a stated value at the outset and pays by reference to it after a total loss. Market value means the insurer pays what the item would have fetched just before the loss.
Terminology varies between insurers, and not every policy uses the phrase "agreed value". What matters is the basis of settlement written into your wording.
For example, one high-value wording requires higher-value items to be specified individually on the schedule. For those items, it says "We will pay the amount shown for those items in the valuation." For unspecified art and antiques, it pays market value or replacement cost, within the sum insured.
| Basis | How the claim is valued | Main advantage | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specified item, settled on the scheduled valuation | Value stated on the schedule | Certainty on a total loss | Value needs keeping current |
| Market value | What the item would have sold for immediately before the loss | No need to schedule | Dispute over value after the event |
| Replacement cost | Cost of buying an equivalent item | Reflects retail prices | Some items cannot be replaced |
| Unspecified, within a single-article limit | Market or replacement, capped per item | Simple for lower-value items | Valuable items may exceed the cap |
Who should value art and jewellery for insurance?
An independent valuer with formal training and experience in the relevant field should value art and jewellery for insurance. For art and antiques, RICS points consumers to its chartered arts and antiques surveyors. It notes that many prepare valuations to ensure sufficient cover on home insurance.
You can check a surveyor's membership through RICS. Members use FRICS, MRICS or AssocRICS after their name. RICS notes that not every firm on its "Find a Surveyor" site is an RICS-regulated firm.
For jewellery and watches, many owners use a specialist jewellery valuer. The National Association of Jewellers runs the Institute of Registered Valuers, its jewellery valuation body.
Ask for the valuer's name and experience with their proposal. Check that the valuation firm carries professional indemnity insurance.
What should a good insurance valuation include?
A good insurance valuation gives enough detail for an insurer, loss adjuster or police officer to identify the item and agree its value. It should include a detailed description, photographs, provenance if known, and the item's location.
A practical checklist:
| Element | What to include |
|---|---|
| Description | Artist or maker, title, medium, dimensions, date, materials, marks and signatures |
| Jewellery specifics | Metal and hallmarks, stone types, carat weights, cut, colour and clarity grades |
| Photographs | Clear images of front, back, signatures, hallmarks and any distinguishing features |
| Certificates | Gemmological reports, watch papers, artist certificates, catalogue raisonné references |
| Provenance | Purchase invoices, exhibition and literature history, previous ownership |
| Condition | Existing damage, restoration or repairs |
| Location | Room or storage location within the home or elsewhere |
| Value and basis | The figure and whether it is retail replacement or another basis |
| Valuer details | Name, qualifications and date of valuation |
Value pairs and sets as a group as well as individually. Our guide to pairs and sets cover explains why.
How often should you revalue art and jewellery?
Revalue art and jewellery regularly, with the interval depending on the type of item and the market. Valuers often advise a yearly valuation for watches, and warn that jewellery valued more than two years ago is likely to be underinsured.
Policies may impose their own timetable. Some high-value wordings require you to review the sums insured for contents, art and antiques and personal valuables at least once a year.
Some wordings reward up-to-date valuations. One pays up to an extra 50% above the scheduled value where the valuation is less than three years old. Overall caps per claim apply, and the cap for personal valuables is lower than for art.
Revalue sooner if an artist's market moves sharply, precious metal or stone prices shift, or an item is restored. Index-linking can help with general contents. It is not a substitute for a valuation of individual high-value pieces.
What are single-article limits?
A single-article limit is the most a policy will pay for any one unspecified item. Above that figure, items usually need to be listed individually on the schedule.
Limits vary widely. One high-value wording caps unspecified art and antiques at £50,000 per item and personal valuables at £25,000. Standard home policies tend to have much lower thresholds.
Missing a single-article limit is one of the most common causes of underinsurance in high-value homes.
Covering valuables in storage, at a vault or when travelling
Tell your insurer where items are kept and how they move. Location affects both the premium and whether cover applies at all.
- At home. Insurers may require safes, alarms or particular locks for jewellery and watches above certain values.
- In a bank or vault. Items kept permanently in a bank vault are often rated differently. Notify the insurer when items move in or out.
- Travelling. Check the territorial limits and any conditions for valuables away from the home. Many high-value wordings cover art and personal valuables anywhere in the world, subject to exclusions.
- In transit. Wordings often exclude transit damage unless the item is "securely and adequately packed."
- On loan or at a restorer. Ask before lending works for exhibition or sending them for conservation.
- Unattended vehicles. Theft from cars is often limited or subject to security conditions, such as items being locked out of sight.
Why do records matter as much as the valuation?
Records matter because a claim depends on proving what you owned and what it was worth. Without records, settlements can be slow and contested.
Keep a single, up-to-date inventory with valuations, photographs, receipts and certificates. Store a copy away from the home, for example in secure cloud storage or with your broker.
Record new acquisitions promptly. Some policies give automatic cover for new purchases for a limited period. One high-value wording, for example, covers new art acquisitions provided you tell the insurer within 60 days of purchase.
What to have ready for a quote
- A list of items worth more than your current single-article limit.
- Current valuations, with the date, basis and valuer of each.
- Photographs, certificates and provenance documents.
- An estimate of total contents value, including unspecified items.
- Where each item is kept, including any bank vault or second home.
- Items that travel with you, are worn regularly or are lent for exhibition.
- Alarm, safe and other security details at each address.
- Your claims history for the last five years.
- Your current schedule and policy wording.
Owners of larger collections in country properties can also speak to our high net worth home insurance team.





