PageID: insights-underinsurance-listed-buildings

    We use cookies to analyse traffic and personalise content. Privacy Policy

    We use cookies

    GDPR Compliant

    We use cookies and similar technologies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse website traffic, and provide personalised content. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies. Learn more in our Privacy Policy

    Back to Insights
    Listed & Heritage Buildings
    listed building insurance
    high-value home insurance

    Underinsurance on Listed and Heritage Buildings

    Underinsurance on a listed building means the sum insured is lower than the true cost of reinstating it. Most policies then apply average, cutting every claim in proportion to the shortfall, including small ones. It is common on listed and heritage buildings, and fixable with a current valuation and the right listed and heritage building insurance.

    By Taurus Risk · Published

    Illustration of a listed Georgian façade only half coloured in, representing underinsurance

    What is underinsurance?

    Underinsurance is when the buildings sum insured is less than the full cost of reinstating the property. For a listed building, that cost includes like-for-like materials, specialist trades, professional fees, debris removal and VAT you cannot recover.

    It is more common than many owners assume. RebuildCostAssessment.com's 2026 data, based on 46,917 rebuild cost assessments, found 67% of UK properties underinsured. For listed properties the figure was 79%.

    Standard valuation shortcuts do not fit listed and heritage buildings. Our guide to listed building rebuild costs explains why.

    A professional reinstatement cost survey is the surest fix, and you may not have to pay for it. For larger properties, some insurers will fund the survey themselves. Some will want to survey a listed property in any case before offering terms. For smaller properties, others may ask you to commission one at your own cost.

    What is the average clause?

    The average clause, also called the condition of average, lets an insurer reduce a claim in proportion to the level of underinsurance. If you insure for 60% of the true value, you may recover only 60% of any loss.

    For example, if a property with a £500,000 rebuild cost is insured for £250,000, claims would be settled at half their value.

    The reasoning is that the premium was calculated on the declared value. If that value is too low, the insurer has been paid for less risk than it is carrying.

    How is average calculated?

    Divide the sum insured by the true reinstatement cost, then multiply by the loss. Policy excesses and limits then apply as normal.

    Illustrative example — round numbers, not a real property or claim.

    StepFigure
    A. True reinstatement cost of a Grade II house and barn£1,000,000
    B. Sum insured on the policy£600,000
    C. Proportion insured (B ÷ A)60%
    D. Cost of repairing a fire in the kitchen wing£200,000
    E. Amount payable (C × D), before any excess£120,000
    F. Shortfall the owner funds£80,000

    The fire damaged only a fraction of the building, yet the owner still bears £80,000. That is the trap: owners often think underinsurance only matters in a total loss.

    How does underinsurance happen on listed and heritage buildings?

    It usually builds up quietly over several years, as values drift and costs are left out. The most common causes are below.

    CauseWhat goes wrong
    Outdated valuationThe figure was set at purchase or many years ago and never reassessed.
    Build cost inflationIndex-linking lags behind traditional material and labour costs.
    Using market valueThe sale price or a purchase valuation is used instead of reinstatement cost.
    Generic calculatorA tool designed for standard modern homes underprices lime, stone, oak and handmade brick.
    Missing feesArchitects', surveyors', engineers' and heritage consultants' fees are left out.
    Missing debris and demolitionClearing a damaged site, especially with asbestos, is not allowed for.
    Missing VATVAT on the rebuild, fees and debris removal is not included.
    New structuresAn extension, barn conversion, pool or garden wall is added without updating the sum insured.

    Most policies are index-linked or given a general uplift, but no index keeps figures current indefinitely. General indices may also not track traditional materials as closely as modern construction.

    Does day-one reinstatement prevent underinsurance?

    Partly. Day-one reinstatement protects against inflation after inception, but it cannot rescue a declared value that was wrong at the start.

    Under this basis you declare the reinstatement cost at the start of the policy period. The insurer adds an agreed uplift to absorb inflation during the year and through the rebuild, and average is typically assessed against the declared value.

    If the "day one" figure is based on an old or generic estimate, average can still apply. Terms vary between insurers, so check your wording.

    Illustrative example: a declared value of £1,000,000 with a 30% uplift gives a maximum of £1,300,000. If the true day-one cost was £1,000,000, a rebuild that later costs £1,250,000 would be covered in full, subject to the policy terms.

    Are there other policy bases?

    Yes, though each needs careful agreement with the insurer and is a deliberate choice, not a fix for an old valuation.

    • Average waiver. Some insurers agree not to apply average where a recent professional valuation supports the sum insured.
    • First loss. Some clients choose to insure on a first loss limit. This is a deliberate choice to insure the property partially, not to its full value. The insurer agrees not to apply average up to that limit, but you carry anything above it. It is more common for large estates and complex sites than for single homes.
    • Repair and restoration basis. For some traditional buildings, such as certain churches, insurers may value on the cost of repair and restoration rather than full reconstruction. This assumes surviving walls would remain standing after a severe fire.

    Make sure you understand exactly what risk you are retaining under any of these bases.

    How do I fix underinsurance on a listed or heritage building?

    Start with a current reinstatement cost assessment from a chartered surveyor who understands historic buildings. The ABI says listed and non-standard homes may need a surveyor rather than a calculator.

    Then follow these steps:

    1. Check every building on the site. Include barns, stables, walls, pools and driveways.
    2. Confirm what is included. Fees, demolition, debris removal and VAT should all be visible in the figure.
    3. Choose the basis. Consider day-one reinstatement, and whether your insurer offers an average waiver backed by the valuation.
    4. Diarise the next review. Revisit the rebuild cost every three to five years, or sooner after alterations.
    5. Tell your broker about changes. Extensions, conversions and major restorations change the figure.

    Increasing the sum insured will usually increase the premium. That cost is small compared with self-funding a share of every claim.

    What to have ready for a sum insured review

    • Your current policy schedule and wording
    • The figure, date and author of your last valuation
    • The list entry and grade or category, if the building is listed
    • Construction of the walls, roof, floors and framing, and the age of each part
    • Floor areas, or existing plans and surveys
    • Details of any extensions, conversions or restorations since that valuation
    • Any planned or ongoing works
    • How each part of the building is used
    • A list of every outbuilding, wall and hard surface on the site
    • Whether you can recover VAT

    Frequently asked questions

    How Taurus can help

    Taurus Risk is an independent, FCA-authorised broker. We compare insurers with appetite for listed and heritage buildings and a strong record of handling large heritage claims. We also review sums insured and explain how average and day-one reinstatement work in your wording.

    Find out more about our listed and heritage building insurance service. Owners of listed homes can also speak to our private client insurance team, and owners of high-value homes may find our guide to underinsurance on high-value homes useful.

    For the wider picture, read our pillar guide to insuring a listed building. To have your figures checked, request a quote, call 020 3958 2070 or email Enquiries@Taurus-Risk.com. We aim to give you a response within 24 working hours.

    Get a listed and heritage quote

    This guide provides general information, not individual insurance or legal advice. Cover is subject to policy terms, conditions and exclusions.

    Related guides

    Listed building rebuild costHow Much Does Listed Building Insurance Cost? (2026)Insuring a Listed Building: The Complete UK Guide (2026)
    Related Insights

    Listed & Heritage Building Insurance Industry Insights

    Stay informed with our latest insights, guides, and expert analysis specifically relevant to the listed & heritage building insurance sector.

    Insuring a Listed Building: The Complete UK Guide (2026)
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Insuring a Listed Building: The Complete UK Guide (2026)

    Insuring a listed building? Learn how like-for-like rebuild, consent and heritage claims work, how to avoid underinsurance, and how a broker can help.

    Listed Hotel Insurance: What Owners and Operators Need to Know
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Listed Hotel Insurance: What Owners and Operators Need to Know

    Listed hotel insurance explained: heritage rebuild values, longer business interruption, fire risk and who insures what. Speak to a Taurus broker today.

    Listed Pub Insurance: Covering Historic Inns and Free Houses
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Listed Pub Insurance: Covering Historic Inns and Free Houses

    Listed pub insurance explained: thatched and timber-framed inns, rebuild cost vs sale value, business interruption and leases. Get broker advice today.

    Listed Commercial Building Insurance: Offices, Shops and Mixed-Use
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Listed Commercial Building Insurance: Offices, Shops and Mixed-Use

    Listed commercial building insurance for landlords: FRI leases, flats above shops, loss of rent, liability and empty units. Speak to a Taurus broker.

    Listed Building Rebuild Costs: Why Your Sum Insured Is Probably Wrong
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Listed Building Rebuild Costs: Why Your Sum Insured Is Probably Wrong

    Rebuild cost for a listed building is rarely market value. See what a reinstatement cost assessment includes, avoid underinsurance and ask a broker.

    Underinsurance on Listed and Heritage Buildings
    Listed & Heritage Buildings

    Underinsurance on Listed and Heritage Buildings

    Underinsurance on a listed building lets the average clause cut every claim. See why it happens, how to fix it and get your sum insured checked.

    FCA Regulated Broker

    Independent Listed Building Insurance Advice

    We compare insurers with appetite for listed and heritage buildings and a strong record of handling large heritage claims.

    • Specialist heritage insurer comparison
    • Reinstatement values and policy bases explained
    • Support with heritage claims
    Get a Quote

    A response within 24 working hours, no obligation

    Related Specialisms

    Explore the specialist cover most relevant to this guide.

    listed building insurance

    Underinsurance on a listed building lets the average clause cut every claim. See why it happens, how to fix it and get your sum insured checked.

    View listed building insurance

    high-value home insurance

    Underinsurance on a listed building lets the average clause cut every claim. See why it happens, how to fix it and get your sum insured checked.

    View high-value home insurance

    commercial property insurance

    Buildings and loss of rent cover for commercial heritage property.

    View commercial property insurance
    CallGet a Quick Quote
    32 Reviews
    REVIEWS.io
    5 Rating
    32 Reviews
    Shannon
    Verified Customer
    Billy was very helpful in helping me arrange my insurance. He was prompt when replying to emails, knowledgeable and friendly. Thank you Taurus Risk Management!
    Edward
    Verified Customer
    V. responsive and helpful in pulling together and agreeing a quote for buildings insuruance. Would recommend
    Jack
    Verified Customer
    We engaged Taurus Risk to advise on and place cover for a large residential building in North London. Thomas in particular was fantastic, provided timely and well thought out advice, and more importantly advised us appropriately for the risk we needed to cover. We ended up moving from our previous broker as the service and options for cover was far better than what our previous broker was offering. I stand behind and would definitely recommend Taurus Risk.
    Robert
    Verified Customer
    Chris was brilliant - he really helped us out to find a competitive quote when we were having trouble with other brokers. He turned a quote around in record time and was diligent and helpful. We will definitely be using Taurus again next year.
    Beverley
    Verified Customer
    Our needs were assessed and understood. We received a timeous and properly considered solution in a very short space of time. An absolute pleasure.
    Camilla
    Verified Customer
    Chris was a pleasure to deal with. He was very responsive, provided an excellent service and was professional. I would recommend Taurus who are reliable and efficient, and get you the best deal.
    Raj
    Verified Customer
    Very professional took time to listen and set my cover accordingly pleaseure to deal with. Thank you!
    Imran
    Verified Customer
    I found Taurus online last year and this is my second year I am using Taurus for my Insurance renewal. Chris and Billy have both been very good to me and our relationship is not just about me asking for a insurance policy but we have a general chat which makes a huge difference when deciding should I shop around or actually Taurus take care of me so why should I have to look elsewhere. The pricing is competitive and I receive good advice. I am happy I have found an excellent organisation
    Sairah
    Verified Customer
    Had a very competitive quote from Chris Foster - multi property, including rent cover. Gone ahead with the policy, and hope the underwriters will be a good solution, should anything occur.
    Jonathon
    Verified Customer
    Tom and Billy of Taurus Risk Management provide a highly personalised and commercially focused service. They take the time to ensure that clients fully understand their insurance policies and that cover arrangements are aligned with their specific requirements. Their approach is centred on understanding each client's budget, objectives, and any operational constraints, enabling them to source the most suitable and competitive insurance solutions available. Combined with their professional, approachable, and responsive manner, they instil confidence throughout the process and make it clear that you are working with a trusted and knowledgeable team. I would have no hesitation in recommending Taurus Risk Management to individuals and businesses seeking expert insurance advice and exceptional client service.
    Suzie
    Verified Customer
    Quick and easy process, Chris was very helpful in ensuring we get the right cover for a reasonable price. Would highly recommend.
    Clare
    Verified Customer
    Chris helped me secure buildings insurance for a group of 6 residential buildings - a mix HMO and flats, he obtained several quotes for me to consider and the price was very competitive. The service was brilliant and I would definitely use Taurus risk management again.
    Alexandra
    Verified Customer
    I recently purchased house and travel insurance through Taurus Risk and had an excellent experience. From the initial communication to their prompt and efficient responses, the team demonstrated a high level of professionalism throughout. They addressed all of my questions quickly and provided clear, valuable advice. I would highly recommend Taurus Risk to anyone seeking a reliable and knowledgeable insurance broker.
    Warren
    Verified Customer
    It was an absolute pleasure working with Taurus. From the beginning it felt like the team had a genuine interest in my priorities and what was most important. Looking forward to our partnership together.
    Meg
    Verified Customer
    Team Taurus did a great job - providing fantastic client service. We are very happy with our insurance coverage.