What is underinsurance?
Underinsurance is when the buildings sum insured is less than the full cost of reinstating the property. For a listed building, that cost includes like-for-like materials, specialist trades, professional fees, debris removal and VAT you cannot recover.
It is more common than many owners assume. RebuildCostAssessment.com's 2026 data, based on 46,917 rebuild cost assessments, found 67% of UK properties underinsured. For listed properties the figure was 79%.
Standard valuation shortcuts do not fit listed and heritage buildings. Our guide to listed building rebuild costs explains why.
A professional reinstatement cost survey is the surest fix, and you may not have to pay for it. For larger properties, some insurers will fund the survey themselves. Some will want to survey a listed property in any case before offering terms. For smaller properties, others may ask you to commission one at your own cost.
What is the average clause?
The average clause, also called the condition of average, lets an insurer reduce a claim in proportion to the level of underinsurance. If you insure for 60% of the true value, you may recover only 60% of any loss.
For example, if a property with a £500,000 rebuild cost is insured for £250,000, claims would be settled at half their value.
The reasoning is that the premium was calculated on the declared value. If that value is too low, the insurer has been paid for less risk than it is carrying.
How is average calculated?
Divide the sum insured by the true reinstatement cost, then multiply by the loss. Policy excesses and limits then apply as normal.
Illustrative example — round numbers, not a real property or claim.
| Step | Figure |
|---|---|
| A. True reinstatement cost of a Grade II house and barn | £1,000,000 |
| B. Sum insured on the policy | £600,000 |
| C. Proportion insured (B ÷ A) | 60% |
| D. Cost of repairing a fire in the kitchen wing | £200,000 |
| E. Amount payable (C × D), before any excess | £120,000 |
| F. Shortfall the owner funds | £80,000 |
The fire damaged only a fraction of the building, yet the owner still bears £80,000. That is the trap: owners often think underinsurance only matters in a total loss.
How does underinsurance happen on listed and heritage buildings?
It usually builds up quietly over several years, as values drift and costs are left out. The most common causes are below.
| Cause | What goes wrong |
|---|---|
| Outdated valuation | The figure was set at purchase or many years ago and never reassessed. |
| Build cost inflation | Index-linking lags behind traditional material and labour costs. |
| Using market value | The sale price or a purchase valuation is used instead of reinstatement cost. |
| Generic calculator | A tool designed for standard modern homes underprices lime, stone, oak and handmade brick. |
| Missing fees | Architects', surveyors', engineers' and heritage consultants' fees are left out. |
| Missing debris and demolition | Clearing a damaged site, especially with asbestos, is not allowed for. |
| Missing VAT | VAT on the rebuild, fees and debris removal is not included. |
| New structures | An extension, barn conversion, pool or garden wall is added without updating the sum insured. |
Most policies are index-linked or given a general uplift, but no index keeps figures current indefinitely. General indices may also not track traditional materials as closely as modern construction.
Does day-one reinstatement prevent underinsurance?
Partly. Day-one reinstatement protects against inflation after inception, but it cannot rescue a declared value that was wrong at the start.
Under this basis you declare the reinstatement cost at the start of the policy period. The insurer adds an agreed uplift to absorb inflation during the year and through the rebuild, and average is typically assessed against the declared value.
If the "day one" figure is based on an old or generic estimate, average can still apply. Terms vary between insurers, so check your wording.
Illustrative example: a declared value of £1,000,000 with a 30% uplift gives a maximum of £1,300,000. If the true day-one cost was £1,000,000, a rebuild that later costs £1,250,000 would be covered in full, subject to the policy terms.
Are there other policy bases?
Yes, though each needs careful agreement with the insurer and is a deliberate choice, not a fix for an old valuation.
- Average waiver. Some insurers agree not to apply average where a recent professional valuation supports the sum insured.
- First loss. Some clients choose to insure on a first loss limit. This is a deliberate choice to insure the property partially, not to its full value. The insurer agrees not to apply average up to that limit, but you carry anything above it. It is more common for large estates and complex sites than for single homes.
- Repair and restoration basis. For some traditional buildings, such as certain churches, insurers may value on the cost of repair and restoration rather than full reconstruction. This assumes surviving walls would remain standing after a severe fire.
Make sure you understand exactly what risk you are retaining under any of these bases.
How do I fix underinsurance on a listed or heritage building?
Start with a current reinstatement cost assessment from a chartered surveyor who understands historic buildings. The ABI says listed and non-standard homes may need a surveyor rather than a calculator.
Then follow these steps:
- Check every building on the site. Include barns, stables, walls, pools and driveways.
- Confirm what is included. Fees, demolition, debris removal and VAT should all be visible in the figure.
- Choose the basis. Consider day-one reinstatement, and whether your insurer offers an average waiver backed by the valuation.
- Diarise the next review. Revisit the rebuild cost every three to five years, or sooner after alterations.
- Tell your broker about changes. Extensions, conversions and major restorations change the figure.
Increasing the sum insured will usually increase the premium. That cost is small compared with self-funding a share of every claim.
What to have ready for a sum insured review
- Your current policy schedule and wording
- The figure, date and author of your last valuation
- The list entry and grade or category, if the building is listed
- Construction of the walls, roof, floors and framing, and the age of each part
- Floor areas, or existing plans and surveys
- Details of any extensions, conversions or restorations since that valuation
- Any planned or ongoing works
- How each part of the building is used
- A list of every outbuilding, wall and hard surface on the site
- Whether you can recover VAT






