To compare commercial insurance quotes properly, check that every quote is based on the same information, then line up the sums insured and limits, excesses, basis of settlement, exclusions, conditions, optional extensions, the insurer behind the policy and the total cost including tax and fees. Only once those match is the price a fair comparison.
Two quotes for the same business can differ by thousands of pounds and still both be "right", because they rarely insure exactly the same thing. One may carry a higher excess, exclude a peril the other includes, or attach a condition your premises cannot meet. Those differences usually only surface when a claim is made, which is the worst time to find them. This guide sets out the checks a commercial broker runs before recommending a policy.
Related cover: SME Package
Start With the Same Information
Every quote is the insurer's response to the information it was given. If one insurer was told the building has a sprinkler system and another was not, or one was given last year's turnover and another this year's, the quotes are pricing different risks.
Under the Insurance Act 2015, commercial policyholders have a duty to make a fair presentation of the risk before cover starts. If something material is left out or misstated, the insurer may be entitled to reduce a claim payment, apply different terms or, in serious cases, avoid the policy. So the first check is not on the quote at all: it is on the presentation behind it.
Before comparing, confirm that each quote reflects the same:
- Business activities and turnover, including any work you do only occasionally
- Premises details: construction, age, occupancy, security and fire protection
- Sums insured and the period of cover required
- Claims history, for the period insurers ask about, commonly the last three to five years
- Any known issues, such as unoccupied areas, cladding, flood history or ongoing disputes
Our guide to what affects commercial property insurance quotes explains which details insurers weigh most heavily.
Line Up Sums Insured and Limits
The sum insured or limit of indemnity is the most an insurer will pay. It is also the easiest place for a cheaper quote to save money without you noticing.
- Buildings: should generally reflect the full rebuild (reinstatement) cost, including demolition, site clearance and professional fees, not the market value. Our guide to commercial building insurance explains why the two figures can differ significantly.
- Contents, stock and equipment: check whether values are on a new replacement basis or something lower.
- Business interruption: compare the basis of cover (gross profit, revenue or increased cost of working only), the sum insured and the indemnity period. A 12-month indemnity period costs less than 24 months, but only helps if you could fully recover within a year. Our guide to whether business interruption insurance is worth it for an office explains how to set it.
- Liability: compare the limit and whether it applies per occurrence, in the aggregate for the policy period, or both. Employers' liability has a legal minimum of £5 million for most employers, and many policies provide £10 million.
- Professional indemnity: check whether the limit applies to each and every claim or in the aggregate, and whether defence costs sit within the limit or are paid in addition to it.
Underinsurance and average
Many property policies include an average condition. If the sum insured is lower than the true value, a claim may be reduced in proportion. For example, if a building that would cost £2 million to rebuild is insured for £1.5 million, a claim may only be paid at 75% of the loss. A lower premium achieved through a lower sum insured is not a saving.
Compare Excesses Section by Section
Excesses are rarely a single figure. A quote may show a modest standard excess but a much higher one for escape of water, subsidence, theft, unoccupied buildings or storm damage. Some liability and professional indemnity policies also carry excesses that apply to defence costs.
Set the excesses for each quote out next to each other, section by section, and ask which perils are most likely to produce a claim for your business. A lower premium bought with a higher excess on your most likely claim is often a poor trade. Our guide to reducing office insurance costs covers when a higher voluntary excess can make sense.
Check the Basis of Settlement
Two policies with the same sum insured can pay out very differently depending on how claims are settled.
- Reinstatement basis generally pays to repair or replace with new property of the same standard.
- Indemnity basis generally pays the value at the time of the loss, with a deduction for wear and tear.
- Day one reinstatement, offered by some insurers on buildings, lets you declare the rebuild cost at the start of the policy with an agreed uplift to allow for inflation. Average usually only applies if that declared value was too low at the outset.
Read the Exclusions and Endorsements
Standard policy wordings from different insurers often look similar. The differences tend to sit in two places: the exclusions within the wording, and the endorsements attached to the specific quote.
Endorsements are where an insurer changes standard cover for your risk. Common examples include flood exclusions or higher excesses in flood-prone areas, restrictions once a property becomes unoccupied, exclusions for particular activities, and minimum security requirements. An endorsement attached to one quote and not another can make the cheaper quote materially narrower.
Our guide to office insurance exclusions shows the kind of wording to look out for in a typical package, and our portfolio landlord exclusions guide covers the equivalent points for landlords.
Independent Commercial Property Insurance Advice
Taurus Risk is an independent, FCA-regulated specialist insurance broker. We aim to explain how to compare commercial insurance quotes like for like in plain terms and to support clients through renewals and claims.
- Access to UK insurers that write commercial property risks
- Commercial property wordings explained in plain terms
- Support from a named broker
A response within 24 working hours, no obligation
Look Closely at Conditions, Warranties and Subjectivities
Conditions and warranties are obligations you must meet for cover to operate. Subjectivities are things the insurer needs before or shortly after cover starts, such as a survey, an electrical inspection certificate or a signed proposal form.
Typical examples include:
- Intruder alarm conditions requiring a maintained, monitored system that is set whenever the premises are closed
- Inspection conditions for unoccupied buildings, often weekly
- Requirements for periodic electrical testing, hot works permits or regular waste removal
- "Subject to survey", meaning terms can change after the insurer's surveyor visits
The Insurance Act 2015 limits an insurer's ability to decline a claim for breach of a term that could not have increased the risk of the loss that actually happened. That protection is useful, but it does not make conditions optional. A quote with conditions your business cannot meet in practice is not a real alternative.
Compare What Is Included, Not Just What Is Offered
Quotes often differ in which extensions are built in and which are optional extras. Before comparing prices, check each quote for:
- Accidental damage
- Loss of rent or business interruption
- Terrorism, often available as an optional extension on commercial property
- Legal expenses
- Glass, locks and keys, and trace and access for leaks
- Cyber, which is often excluded from property and liability policies and usually needs a standalone cyber policy
If one quote includes an extension and another prices it separately, add that cost before comparing.
Check Who Is Behind the Quote
The same premium can buy a very different experience at claim time. Useful questions include:
- Who is the insurer? Some policies are issued by an insurance company, some by Lloyd's syndicates, and some through managing general agents acting under an insurer's authority.
- How strong is the insurer financially? Brokers typically check financial strength ratings and the insurer's appetite for your type of business.
- Who handles claims? Some insurers manage claims in house; others use third-party administrators or loss adjusters.
- How settled is its appetite? An insurer with a stable, long-term appetite for your class of business is less likely to withdraw or re-rate sharply at renewal.
Compare the Total Cost
Make sure each figure is complete and comparable:
- Is Insurance Premium Tax included? Most commercial insurance premiums carry it, so check whether each figure is shown with or without it.
- Are broker or administration fees charged on top?
- If paying by instalments, what does the credit arrangement cost compared with paying annually?
- Is the price for 12 months, or for a different period?
- Does it depend on a long-term agreement, and if so, on what terms?
You can also ask any broker how they are paid, whether by commission, fee or both.
A Quick Comparison Checklist
| What to compare | Why it matters | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Information presented | Quotes priced on different facts are not comparable | Was every insurer given the same, current information? |
| Sums insured and limits | Lower limits mean lower premiums and smaller payouts | Do the limits match rebuild costs, values and contracts? |
| Excesses | Peril-specific excesses can be far higher than the headline figure | What is the excess on our most likely claim? |
| Basis of settlement | Indemnity settlement deducts for wear and tear | Is it reinstatement or indemnity, and is day one cover offered? |
| Endorsements | They change standard cover for your risk | What has been added to or removed from the standard wording? |
| Conditions and subjectivities | Non-compliance can restrict cover | Can we meet every condition in practice? |
| Extensions | Included cover differs between insurers | Which extensions are included and which cost extra? |
| Insurer and claims service | Price does not reflect claims experience | Who issues the policy and who handles claims? |
| Total cost | Tax, fees and finance charges vary | What is the full annual cost? |
When a Broker Adds Value
Comparison sites can work well for simple, low-value risks. For most commercial property, liability and professional risks, the useful work happens before the quote: presenting the business fully, approaching insurers whose appetite fits, and negotiating the wording as well as the price. A broker can also set quotes out side by side with the differences highlighted.
Start early. For most commercial risks, 60 to 90 days before renewal gives insurers time to review, survey if needed and compete properly. Our guide on how to choose a commercial insurance broker explains what to look for, and our commercial property insurance and office insurance pages show how we approach those markets. For a wider view of the risks your cover should respond to, see business risk management explained.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare commercial insurance quotes?
Check that each quote is based on the same information, then compare sums insured and limits, excesses, basis of settlement, exclusions and endorsements, conditions, included extensions, the insurer and the total cost including Insurance Premium Tax and fees. Price is only a fair comparison once those match.
Why are my commercial insurance quotes so different?
Quotes usually differ because insurers were given different information, have different appetites for the risk, or have quoted different limits, excesses, endorsements or extensions. Two quotes that look similar on the schedule can provide materially different cover.
Is the cheapest commercial insurance quote the best option?
Not necessarily. A lower premium can reflect lower limits, higher excesses, narrower wording or conditions that are difficult to meet. The best value is the quote that covers the risks you actually face on terms you can comply with.
What should I check in the small print of a business insurance quote?
Read the endorsements, exclusions, conditions, warranties and subjectivities attached to each quote, along with the excess for each section. These are where most of the meaningful differences between insurers sit.
How far before renewal should I compare commercial insurance?
For most commercial risks, starting 60 to 90 days before renewal gives insurers time to review the risk, arrange a survey if needed and compete properly. Larger or more complex risks may need longer.
Do commercial insurance quotes include Insurance Premium Tax?
Most commercial insurance premiums are subject to Insurance Premium Tax, but quotes may show figures with or without it. Check each quote is presented on the same basis before comparing.






